MLB hot discussions
Dive into the hottest MLB discussions and debates trending on Reddit.
MLB-topic posts with more than 50 upvotes
- Reddit/r/mlb·Feb 25
Reddit Ranks MLB Ballparks: Wrigley and Fenway Shine, GABP Criticized
Description
A Reddit post ranks major league ballparks for the 2025 season, sparking discussions about the best and worst stadiums, with Wrigley and Fenway receiving top honors for their historical significance.
Key Points
- Users highlight the unique settings of various ballparks, with T-Mobile Park praised for its scenic location next to Puget Sound, while Wrigley and Fenway are deemed S tier for their iconic status.
- Comments reflect a mix of opinions, with some fans expressing disappointment in the ranking of Great American Ball Park, citing its blandness compared to others.
- The discussion also touches on the upcoming Steinbrenner Field for the Rays, with some fans criticizing the presence of Yankees branding, indicating a divide in preferences among fans.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShare - Reddit/r/mlb·Feb 20
Billy Beane's Financial Decision: Signing with the Mets Over College
Description
In a discussion about the film 'Moneyball', users reflect on Billy Beane's pivotal decision to sign with the Mets instead of pursuing college, highlighting the impact of financial choices on his career.
Key Points
- Billy Beane's decision to sign with the Mets over attending college is a significant moment in his life, as referenced in 'Moneyball'.
- The film illustrates Beane's regret over prioritizing money in his early career, shaping his future decisions in baseball management.
- Users share insights on the flashback scene where Beane discusses his contract offer with his parents, emphasizing the weight of financial decisions in sports.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShare - Reddit/r/mlb·Feb 20
Fans Debate Accuracy of New Automated Ball-Strike System in MLB
Description
A Reddit post raises questions about the accuracy of the new Automated Ball-Strike System (ABS) in tracking calls, sparking a lively discussion among fans about its potential impact on the game.
Key Points
- Fans express optimism about the ABS's accuracy, with some predicting it will be nearly perfect based on its minor league performance and existing technology.
- Concerns are raised about discrepancies between the ABS and traditional umpire calls, with some anticipating fan reactions when the TV box doesn't match the calls.
- The ABS is viewed as a challenge system rather than a complete replacement for umpires, with many fans eager to see how it will affect game dynamics and player interactions.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShare - Reddit/r/mlb·Feb 20
Key MLB Developments Since 2016: Teams, Players, and Transactions to Know
Description
A Reddit user seeks a summary of key MLB developments since 2016, including team performance changes, breakout players, and significant transactions, to catch up before spring training.
Key Points
- Teams like the San Diego Padres and Atlanta Braves have transformed from struggling franchises to playoff contenders, showcasing significant improvements.
- Breakout players such as Shohei Ohtani and Fernando Tatis Jr. have emerged, altering the landscape of the league with their exceptional performances.
- Major transactions, including trades and free-agent signings, have reshaped team dynamics, with players like Gerrit Cole and Mookie Betts making impactful moves to new teams.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShare - Reddit/r/mlb·Feb 18
DBacks Secure Shortstop Perdomo with Multi-Year Extension, Building Young Core
Description
The Arizona Diamondbacks have extended shortstop Geraldo Perdomo's contract through 2030, reflecting a strategic move to secure a young core of players for future seasons.
Key Points
- Perdomo's extension is a four-year deal worth $45 million, with a club option for 2030, indicating a low-risk investment in his potential.
- The Diamondbacks are focusing on building a young core, including players like Corbin Carroll and Ketel Marte, ensuring competitive depth for years to come.
- Perdomo has shown improvement in both offensive and defensive skills, contributing to the team's overall strategy of locking in promising talent.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShare - Reddit/r/mlb·Feb 17
Ted Williams: Underrated Greatness and the Flaws of Baseball Voting
Description
A Reddit post argues that Ted Williams is underrated due to missed playing years during WWII and unfair MVP voting, criticizing baseball voters for their biases against him.
Key Points
- Ted Williams missed three full seasons due to WWII, which likely cost him significant career statistics, including over 100 home runs and 390 RBIs.
- Despite leading the league in multiple categories before and after the war, Williams was denied MVP awards, allegedly due to media bias against him.
- The author expresses strong disdain for baseball voters, emphasizing that Williams' Hall of Fame induction should be the only measure of his greatness, regardless of voting controversies.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShare - Reddit/r/mlb·Feb 16
Excitement Builds as Pitchers and Catchers Report for Spring Training
Description
A Reddit post announces the arrival of pitchers and catchers for Spring Training, generating excitement among fans as they anticipate the upcoming MLB season and Opening Day.
Key Points
- The post highlights the significance of pitchers and catchers reporting, marking the official start of Spring Training and the countdown to the MLB season.
- Fans express their enthusiasm in the comments, with one user exclaiming their love for the sport and others sharing their excitement for Spring Training.
- The community engagement reflects a shared anticipation for baseball, showcasing the passion and camaraderie among MLB fans as they prepare for the new season.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShare - Reddit/r/mlb·Feb 10
Excitement Builds for Baseball Season in Sox Fans' Reddit Discussion
Description
A Reddit post titled 'Almost that time of Year…Go Sox' expresses excitement for the upcoming baseball season, generating a lively discussion among fans with various comments supporting different teams.
Key Points
- The post has received 78 upvotes and sparked 6 comments, showcasing enthusiasm for the baseball season's approach.
- Commenters express diverse sentiments, with some rallying for the White Sox while others mention different teams like the Braves.
- The conversation reflects a mix of excitement and humor, with fans engaging in light-hearted banter about the state of their teams and the anticipation of the season.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShare - Reddit/r/mlb·Feb 7
Pete Alonso's Contract: A Major Bargain for the Mets
Description
Pete Alonso's recent contract with the Mets, valued at 2 years and $54M, is viewed as a significant bargain given his consistent performance and durability in MLB.
Key Points
- Alonso has maintained impressive power numbers, hitting at least 34 home runs each season, showcasing his reliability as a power hitter.
- His career OPS+ of 134 surpasses several Hall of Famers, indicating his offensive prowess and value to the team.
- Despite his strong track record, there is speculation about why other teams did not offer more competitive contracts, suggesting a shift in MLB's approach to player negotiations.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShare - Reddit/r/mlb·Jan 24
Braves Sign Jurickson Profar: A Risky Investment or a Strategic Move?
Description
The Braves have signed Jurickson Profar to a three-year deal, raising questions about the player's inconsistent performance and the Padres' decision not to retain him.
Key Points
- Profar has recorded two 3-WAR seasons in the last three years with the Padres, indicating potential but also inconsistency in his overall career performance.
- The post questions whether the Braves overpaid for Profar, considering his mixed track record and the Padres' lack of effort to keep him.
- The discussion reflects on the implications of Profar's signing for the Braves and the broader MLB landscape, particularly regarding player valuation and team strategies.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShare - Reddit/r/mlb·Jan 22
Ichiro Suzuki Falls Short of Unanimous Vote, Sparking Fan Outrage
Description
Ichiro Suzuki narrowly missed a unanimous Hall of Fame vote, receiving 99.7% support, with one voter opting not to endorse him, igniting debate among fans about the voting process.
Key Points
- The post highlights Ichiro's near-unanimous vote, emphasizing the frustration of fans over the single dissenting vote that prevented him from achieving 100% approval.
- Commenters express strong opinions, with some criticizing the mystery surrounding the voters and others comparing Ichiro's career to Derek Jeter's, sparking heated discussions.
- The conversation reveals a mix of humor and frustration among fans, showcasing the passionate nature of baseball discussions on platforms like Reddit.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShare - Reddit/r/mlb·Jan 20
Debate Erupts Over 2025 MLB Payrolls and Their Impact on Competition
Description
A Reddit post discusses the top payrolls for the 2025 MLB season, sparking a lively debate among fans about spending and competitiveness in baseball.
Key Points
- The post highlights teams with the highest payrolls, prompting comments about their commitment to winning and the impact on the sport's integrity.
- Fans express mixed feelings, with some criticizing high payrolls as detrimental to competitive balance, while others defend teams' spending as necessary for success.
- Notable comments include references to historical performance, with one user pointing out that certain high-payroll teams have won four titles in the last 25 years.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShare
