MLB hot discussions
Dive into the hottest MLB discussions and debates trending on Reddit.
MLB-topic posts with more than 50 upvotes
Chris Sale's Cy Young Win Ignites Passionate MLB Fan Discussions
Description
Chris Sale's remarkable achievement of winning the 2024 NL Cy Young Award has sparked lively discussions among MLB fans, highlighting his comeback from Tommy John surgery and his historic performance.
Key Points
- Sale becomes the 5th player aged 35 or older to win the Cy Young for the first time, showcasing his impressive comeback.
- Fans express admiration for Sale's resilience, particularly noting his return from Tommy John surgery, with comments celebrating his performance.
- The discussion includes debates about the Cy Young voting process, with some fans feeling that other candidates, like Wheeler, were overlooked due to Sale's strong season.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareTigers Fans Celebrate Tarik Skubal's Unanimous Cy Young Award Win
Description
Tarik Skubal's unanimous Cy Young Award win has excited Detroit Tigers fans, as highlighted in a popular Reddit post that received 182 upvotes and sparked engaging discussions among users.
Key Points
- The post celebrates Tarik Skubal's achievement, emphasizing the unanimous nature of his Cy Young win, which reflects his outstanding performance this season.
- Comments from fans express their support and excitement, with some discussing the need for the Tigers to reward Skubal for his success.
- The conversation also touches on other players' performances, with fans humorously noting the unexpected outcomes in the voting process, showcasing the community's engagement and camaraderie.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareAthletics' Future in Limbo: Fans Debate Relocation and Ownership Issues
Description
A Reddit post discusses the uncertain future of the Oakland Athletics, questioning whether they will move to Las Vegas, remain in Sacramento, or face extinction, generating significant fan engagement.
Key Points
- The post has sparked a lively debate among fans about the Athletics' potential relocation, with many expressing frustration over ownership decisions and the team's future.
- Comments reflect a mix of humor and serious concerns, with suggestions ranging from barnstorming tours to returning to Oakland if Las Vegas fails.
- Fans criticize current ownership, particularly John Fisher, and express a desire for the team to remain in Oakland, highlighting the emotional connection to the franchise's history.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareTarik Skubal Wins 2024 AL Cy Young Award, Celebrated by Fans
Description
A Reddit post celebrates Tarik Skubal winning the 2024 AL Cy Young Award, generating excitement among fans and sparking discussions about his achievement and historical context.
Key Points
- The post highlights Skubal's unanimous selection for the AL Cy Young Award, marking a significant milestone in his career.
- Fans discuss the rarity of left-handed pitchers winning the award in both leagues, referencing past winners like Randy Johnson and Steve Carlton.
- The celebration is amplified by the fact that Skubal's achievement coincides with his birthday, adding a personal touch to the accolades.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareDebate Erupts Over Stephen Vogt's Historic Manager of the Year Achievement
Description
A Reddit post celebrating Stephen Vogt's achievement as one of the youngest managers to win Manager of the Year has sparked a lively debate among fans, garnering 111 upvotes and 36 comments.
Key Points
- The post highlights Stephen Vogt's accomplishment of being tied for the fourth youngest manager to win the Manager of the Year award, prompting discussions about the significance of this milestone.
- Commenters express mixed opinions, with some questioning whether this achievement qualifies as 'history' and others defending its importance in the context of MLB history.
- The conversation also touches on broader themes in baseball, such as the nature of records and the subjective interpretation of what constitutes a historic achievement.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareDebate Erupts Over 2024 MLB Managers of the Year Voting Results
Description
A Reddit post discussing the 2024 Managers of the Year has sparked significant debate among fans, with 259 upvotes and 80 comments, highlighting differing opinions on the voting results.
Key Points
- Fans express confusion and frustration over the voting process, particularly regarding Marmol's nomination, with comments questioning the legitimacy of the votes.
- Stephen Vogt receives praise for his recognition, with several commenters celebrating his achievements and expressing support for him as a deserving candidate.
- The discussion reveals a broader sentiment among fans about perceived injustices in award nominations, with some feeling that deserving candidates like Mendy were overlooked in favor of less deserving ones.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareCreative Proposal: MLB Teams Share Juan Soto in Unique Contract Idea
Description
A Reddit post proposes a unique idea where the Yankees, Red Sox, Mets, and Dodgers share Juan Soto, each contributing to a record-breaking contract while rotating his services among them.
Key Points
- The proposal suggests each team pays $200 million for a rotating schedule, allowing Soto to play for each team over 12 years, ensuring competitive play.
- An alternative lottery system is discussed, where teams draw for Soto's services annually, with a monthly rotation during the season for playoff teams.
- The idea has sparked mixed reactions, with some commenters finding it humorous and others questioning its seriousness, reflecting the playful nature of fan discussions in baseball communities.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareRays' New Stadium Delay Sparks Relocation Debate Among Fans
Description
A Reddit post discusses the Tampa Bay Rays' new $1.3 billion stadium, which is now unlikely to be completed by 2028 due to unforeseen events, sparking a lively debate among fans.
Key Points
- The Rays' management cited 'unfortunate' events as reasons for the delay in the new stadium's construction, raising concerns among fans about the team's future in Tampa.
- Commenters suggested alternative solutions, including relocating the team temporarily to cities like Montreal or expediting the transition to a new location.
- The discussion highlighted ongoing frustrations with the current stadium's accessibility and the team's attendance issues, with many fans expressing a desire for the Rays to leave Florida altogether.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareRare Babe Ruth Rookie Card Discovered, Expected to Fetch Over $500,000 at Auction
Description
A rare Babe Ruth rookie card discovered at a Danvers yard sale has ignited excitement in the memorabilia community, with expectations for its auction price to exceed $500,000.
Key Points
- Jeff Gross, a baseball card enthusiast, helped an anonymous man uncover a 1916 Babe Ruth rookie card, part of the rare Morehouse Collection.
- The card is set to auction with a starting bid of $150,000, potentially joining the ranks of the most valuable baseball cards ever sold.
- The find includes 119 cards from the Morehouse Collection, with the auction scheduled to begin on December 8, 2024, attracting significant interest from collectors.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareSoto's Excitement After Dodgers Meeting Sparks Fan Reactions and Speculation
Description
Juan Soto expressed excitement after meeting with the Dodgers, highlighting the allure of playing alongside stars like Betts, Freeman, and Ohtani, which has sparked lively discussions among fans.
Key Points
- Soto's positive reaction to the Dodgers meeting suggests a strong interest in joining a competitive team with star players, enhancing his market appeal.
- Fans reacted humorously to the news, with many comments reflecting skepticism about the meeting's significance and Soto's potential signing.
- The discussion reveals a mix of hope and frustration among fans regarding Soto's future, with some expressing a desire for him to join their teams instead of the Dodgers.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareSoto's Decision Ignites Debate on Best Fit Among MLB Teams
Description
A Reddit post discusses Juan Soto's decision to deny the Yankees' qualifying offer, prompting speculation about his best fit among teams like the Dodgers, Mets, Red Sox, or Yankees, generating significant fan engagement.
Key Points
- The post has sparked 292 comments, with fans debating Soto's potential landing spots and the implications for various MLB teams.
- Commenters express diverse opinions on team spending, competitiveness, and the overall state of baseball, highlighting frustrations with ownership and management decisions.
- The conversation reflects a mix of humor and serious analysis, showcasing the community's passion for baseball and player movements in the offseason.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareMets' Steve Cohen Ready to Outbid for Juan Soto, Sparking Fan Debate
Description
A Reddit post discusses rumors surrounding Juan Soto's potential contract with the Mets, highlighting owner Steve Cohen's willingness to offer $50 million more than competing offers, igniting fan debates on the implications.
Key Points
- Steve Cohen is reportedly ready to pay Juan Soto $50 million over other offers, indicating a strong interest in acquiring the star player.
- Fans express mixed feelings about the potential contract, with some fearing the financial burden of a long-term deal for one player.
- The discussion includes humorous comments about agent Scott Boras potentially driving up Soto's price, showcasing the lively nature of fan interactions on the topic.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsSharePaul Skenes Named NL Rookie of the Year, Sparking Fan Excitement
Description
A Reddit post celebrates Paul Skenes being named the National League Rookie of the Year, generating excitement and discussion among fans, evidenced by 104 upvotes and various comments.
Key Points
- The post highlights Paul Skenes' achievement as the NL Rookie of the Year, showcasing his impressive performance throughout the season.
- Comments reflect a mix of humor and debate, with some fans joking about potential future moves and others expressing disbelief over other players being overlooked.
- The engagement indicates strong community support for Skenes, with fans rallying around his recognition and sharing their thoughts on the award's implications.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShare
Debate Erupts Over 2024 MLB Managers of the Year Candidates on Reddit
Description
A Reddit post discussing potential candidates for the 2024 MLB Managers of the Year has sparked lively debate among fans, accumulating 165 upvotes and 62 comments.
Key Points
- Fans express strong opinions on various managers, with comments highlighting support for candidates like Vogt and criticism for Marmol's votes.
- The discussion reveals frustrations over perceived biases in voting, particularly regarding the Cardinals' manager, leading to calls for a recount.
- Overall, the post reflects the passionate engagement of MLB fans in evaluating managerial performances and their impact on team success.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareInnovative Proposal: MLB Teams Share Juan Soto for Competitive Balance
Description
A Reddit post proposes a unique idea where the Yankees, Red Sox, Mets, and Dodgers share Juan Soto, each contributing to a record-breaking contract while ensuring competitive play across teams.
Key Points
- The proposal suggests each team pays $200 million for a rotating schedule with Soto, allowing him to play for each team over 12 years.
- An alternative lottery system is discussed, where teams draw for Soto's services annually, ensuring all teams have a chance to compete with him.
- The idea includes a monthly rotation during playoff seasons, allowing Soto to contribute to multiple teams' postseason runs, enhancing competitiveness in MLB.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareMets' Steve Cohen Ready to Offer Juan Soto $50M More, Sparking Fan Debate
Description
A Reddit post discusses rumors surrounding Juan Soto's potential contract with the Mets, highlighting owner Steve Cohen's willingness to offer $50 million more than competing offers, igniting fan debates on the implications.
Key Points
- Steve Cohen is reportedly prepared to offer Juan Soto a contract exceeding $660 million, showcasing the Mets' aggressive pursuit of top talent.
- Fans express mixed feelings, with some supporting the investment while others worry about the long-term risks of such a massive contract.
- The discussion reveals broader sentiments about player contracts in MLB, with fans debating the value and potential consequences of high-stakes deals.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareSoto's Excitement After Dodgers Meeting Sparks Fan Speculation and Humor
Description
Juan Soto expressed excitement after meeting with the Dodgers, highlighting the allure of playing alongside stars like Betts, Freeman, and Ohtani, which has sparked lively discussions among fans.
Key Points
- Soto's positive reaction to the Dodgers meeting suggests a strong interest in joining a competitive team with star players.
- Fans are debating the implications of Soto's enthusiasm, with some cautioning against reading too much into it as a tactic to increase his market value.
- The Reddit thread features a mix of humor and speculation, showcasing the community's engagement with Soto's potential signing and its impact on various teams.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareRare Babe Ruth Rookie Card Discovered, Expected to Fetch Over $500,000 at Auction
Description
A rare Babe Ruth rookie card discovered at a Danvers yard sale has ignited excitement in the memorabilia community, with expectations for its auction price to exceed $500,000.
Key Points
- Jeff Gross, a baseball card enthusiast, helped an anonymous man uncover a 1916 Babe Ruth rookie card, part of the rare Morehouse Collection.
- The card, expected to fetch at least $500,000, is unique as it has never been seen before in the auction market, making it a significant find.
- The auction for the Ruth card and other collectibles from the Morehouse Collection will begin on December 8, attracting serious collectors and high bids.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsSharePaul Skenes Named NL Rookie of the Year, Igniting Fan Reactions
Description
A Reddit post celebrates Paul Skenes being named the NL Rookie of the Year, generating excitement and discussion among fans, evidenced by 90 upvotes and various comments.
Key Points
- The announcement of Paul Skenes as the NL Rookie of the Year has sparked a lively conversation, with fans expressing their opinions and humor in the comments.
- Some commenters humorously misread the title, while others debate the merits of Skenes versus other candidates, indicating a competitive rookie class.
- The post reflects the community's engagement with MLB awards, showcasing how fans celebrate player achievements and share their thoughts on rookie performances.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareReddit Debate: Comparing Paul Skenes and Russell Wilson Sparks Lively Discussion
Description
A Reddit post comparing MLB player Paul Skenes to NFL quarterback Russell Wilson has sparked a lively discussion, accumulating 654 upvotes and 171 comments, highlighting various opinions on their respective relationships and financial statuses.
Key Points
- The post features comments debating the wealth disparity between Skenes and Wilson, particularly focusing on their significant others, with some noting that Wilson's ex-wife was financially secure post-divorce.
- Users humorously compare iconic moments from Wilson's draft to Skenes' rising profile, showcasing the cultural impact of both athletes in their respective sports.
- The conversation also touches on the talents of college athletes, with some commenters defending the skills of influencers and athletes alike, leading to a mix of serious and comedic exchanges.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareFans Debate Ichiro and CC Sabathia's Hall of Fame Chances in Engaging Reddit Post
Description
A Reddit post discussing potential Hall of Fame inductees, particularly Ichiro and CC Sabathia, has sparked significant engagement, with fans sharing their thoughts on various players' chances of induction.
Key Points
- Ichiro is widely regarded as a lock for the Hall of Fame, with many fans expecting him to receive unanimous support despite concerns about voting biases.
- CC Sabathia is also seen as a likely inductee, while King Felix Hernandez's chances are debated, with some fans feeling he deserves recognition despite not being a first-ballot candidate.
- The discussion reflects nostalgia among fans as they recognize players they grew up watching, highlighting the emotional connection to baseball and its history.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsSharePaul Skanes Named NL 2024 Rookie of the Year, Fans Respond with Humor
Description
Paul Skanes has been awarded the NL 2024 Rookie of the Year, generating significant discussion and humor among fans on Reddit, with 304 upvotes and 139 comments.
Key Points
- The announcement of Skanes as Rookie of the Year sparked a wave of humorous comments, including puns related to his name and musical references.
- Fans engaged in playful banter, with comments like 'Did he start a ska band?' and 'Reel Big Fastball' showcasing the community's creativity.
- The post highlights the excitement surrounding Skanes' achievement and the light-hearted nature of fan interactions in the MLB subreddit.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareDebate Erupts Over Juan Soto's $40 Million Salary Worthiness
Description
A Reddit post questions whether Juan Soto is worth a $40 million annual salary, igniting a heated debate among fans about his future performance and contract value.
Key Points
- The discussion highlights concerns about Soto's potential transition to a designated hitter role and the implications for his long-term value as a player.
- Supporters argue Soto's elite plate discipline and youth (26 years old) justify a high salary, predicting he will maintain productivity into his 30s.
- Critics express skepticism about the risk of decline in performance over a long-term contract, referencing historical examples of players who underperformed in later years.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareDebate Erupts Over MLB's Best Walk-Up Songs on Reddit
Description
A Reddit post discussing the best walk-up songs in MLB has sparked lively debate, with Charlie Blackmon's choice and various fan favorites receiving significant attention and engagement.
Key Points
- The post features Charlie Blackmon's walk-up song, 'I Don't Wanna Lose Your Love,' igniting discussions about the best songs in baseball.
- Fans mention iconic songs like 'Hells Bells' for Trevor Hoffman and 'Careless Whisper' for Zack Greinke, showcasing a range of musical preferences.
- The thread highlights the emotional connection fans have with walk-up songs, often tied to memorable moments and player personalities in MLB history.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareIntense Debate on Rookie of the Year: Skenes vs. Merrill vs. Chourio
Description
A Reddit discussion on who should win the Rookie of the Year award between pitchers Skenes, Merrill, and Chourio has sparked intense debate, with 101 upvotes and 160 comments highlighting differing opinions on their performances.
Key Points
- Many commenters argue that Skenes had a historic rookie season, with impressive stats despite fewer starts, making him a strong contender for the award.
- Others advocate for Merrill, citing his all-star level performance at a premium position and significant contributions to his team's success throughout the season.
- The debate reflects broader discussions about rookie performance metrics, with fans divided on how to weigh traditional stats versus overall impact on the game.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShare
Future of MLB in Question Amid Concerns Over Accessibility and Competition
Description
A Reddit discussion raises concerns about the future popularity of MLB, questioning whether it can compete with the NBA and avoid becoming a niche sport due to issues like blackout restrictions.
Key Points
- Many commenters express frustration over blackout restrictions, which hinder access to games and could deter potential viewers from following MLB.
- The conversation highlights a perceived decline in NBA ratings and suggests that MLB could capitalize on this by improving accessibility to its games.
- Users emphasize the need for MLB to adapt its broadcasting strategies, as current practices may alienate fans and limit the sport's growth in popularity.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareReddit Post Compares Paul Skenes to Russell Wilson, Igniting Fan Humor and Debate
Description
A Reddit post comparing MLB player Paul Skenes to NFL quarterback Russell Wilson has sparked lively discussions, accumulating 310 upvotes and 71 comments, showcasing fan engagement and humor.
Key Points
- The post features a humorous comparison between Paul Skenes and Russell Wilson, highlighting iconic moments from their careers that fans find relatable and entertaining.
- Comments reveal a mix of humor and insight, with users discussing the financial differences between Skenes and Wilson's partners, adding layers to the comparison.
- The engagement level, with over 300 upvotes, indicates a strong interest in the crossover between MLB and NFL discussions among fans, reflecting the community's diverse interests.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareIchiro's Unanimous Induction Expected Amid Debate on Other Candidates
Description
A Reddit discussion anticipates the upcoming Hall of Fame results, focusing on Ichiro's likely induction and the candidacy of other players like CC Sabathia and Felix Hernandez, sparking varied fan opinions.
Key Points
- Ichiro is widely expected to be a unanimous Hall of Fame inductee, with fans expressing concern over potential voting biases against him.
- Felix Hernandez, despite his impressive career, faces uncertainty regarding his induction, with fans divided on his chances due to team performance.
- The conversation highlights frustrations with Hall of Fame voting practices, including the tendency of some writers to withhold votes from deserving candidates for personal reasons.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsSharePaul Skanes Named NL 2024 Rookie of the Year, Fans Celebrate with Humor
Description
Paul Skanes has been awarded the NL 2024 Rookie of the Year, generating significant discussion and humor among fans on Reddit, with 259 upvotes and 121 comments.
Key Points
- The announcement of Skanes as Rookie of the Year sparked a wave of humorous comments, including jokes about his name and potential band names.
- Fans expressed their excitement, with some noting the increased value of his trading cards following the award.
- The post highlights the community's engagement, showcasing how MLB fans celebrate player achievements with light-hearted banter and camaraderie.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareFans Debate Corporate Naming Rights After Stadium Renamed to Daikin
Description
A Reddit post discusses the renaming of a stadium to Daikin, an HVAC company, sparking a lively debate among fans about corporate naming rights and the loss of traditional stadium identities.
Key Points
- Fans express frustration over the trend of corporate naming rights, with many preferring more dignified, permanent names for stadiums.
- Comments highlight various examples of poorly received stadium names, including Guaranteed Rate Field and loanDepot Park, showcasing a shared disdain for commercialization.
- The discussion also touches on the quality of stadium amenities, particularly air conditioning, and how corporate sponsors should improve facilities associated with their names.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareDebate Heats Up Over MLB Rookie of the Year: Skenes, Merrill, or Chourio?
Description
A Reddit discussion centers on the debate over which rookie player deserves the prestigious award, focusing on Skenes, Merrill, and Chourio, with strong opinions and statistics supporting each candidate.
Key Points
- Skenes is praised for his historic rookie season, being a Cy Young finalist despite limited innings pitched, sparking debate about his qualifications.
- Merrill's impressive performance at a premium position, including a .292 average and 24 home runs, garners significant support from fans who argue he deserves the award.
- The conversation highlights differing opinions on player value, with some emphasizing traditional stats while others focus on overall contributions and team context, showcasing the complexity of rookie evaluations.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareDetroit Tigers' 2024 Success Sparks Fan Excitement and Future Optimism
Description
A Reddit post highlights the Detroit Tigers' remarkable performance in 2024, sparking discussions among fans about their playoff journey and future potential.
Key Points
- The Tigers' unexpected success in 2024 caught the attention of fans, especially as they capitalized on the struggles of other teams like the Twins.
- Key moments, such as Kerry Carpenter's crucial home run in the playoffs, are celebrated by fans, showcasing the team's resilience.
- Fans express optimism for the Tigers' future, with discussions about their potential to build on this year's achievements and improve next season.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareRed Sox Fans Speculate on New Dominican Stars Amid Pedro Martinez Anniversary
Description
A Reddit post commemorates the 27th anniversary of the Red Sox acquiring Pedro Martinez, sparking speculation about potential new Dominican stars joining the team, particularly Amed Rosario.
Key Points
- The post highlights the historical significance of Pedro Martinez's acquisition, prompting discussions about current player trades and acquisitions.
- Commenters speculate on Amed Rosario as a possible addition to the Red Sox, with mixed opinions on his potential impact.
- The conversation also includes debates about other players, such as Juan Soto, and their likelihood of joining Boston, showcasing fan perspectives from both Red Sox and Yankees supporters.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareDebate Erupts Over Rarity of 50 Doubles and 50 Home Runs in MLB History
Description
A Reddit post discusses the rarity of achieving 50 doubles and 50 home runs in a season, sparking a lively debate among fans about past players and their performances.
Key Points
- The post highlights the historical significance of the 50-50 achievement, questioning if it will ever be replicated in modern baseball.
- Commenters reflect on past players like Mo Vaughn and Albert Belle, discussing how personality and media relations impacted MVP voting outcomes.
- The conversation reveals differing opinions on what constitutes a 'valuable' player versus the 'best' player, showcasing the complexities of award voting in MLB.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShareReddit Community Engages to Identify Signature on Broken MLB Bat
Description
A Reddit post seeks help identifying a signature on a broken Louisville Slugger bat found by the user's father, sparking a lively discussion among MLB fans.
Key Points
- The post has gained attention with 63 upvotes and 26 comments, showcasing community engagement in identifying the signature.
- Commenters suggest various players, including Nomar Garciaparra, with some debating the likelihood based on bat usage and signature style.
- The discussion also touches on the bat's material, indicating it is an ash bat, which may date it to 10-15 years ago, adding context to the signature's potential owner.
linkCopy linkshare_windowsShare